Headline »

Japanese Consulate San Francisco Vice Consul Charged with Assualt and 14 Counts of Domestic Violence

May 9, 2012 – 5:58 am |

An interesting turn of events that should test the diplomatic will of Japan and the  application of domestic and international law. The LA TImes reports:
“A Japanese consulate official faces felony charges after San Mateo County …

Read the full story »
LIFE IN JAPAN

News, information and discussion on life in Japan. Have an interesting story or video to share, contact me! Be sure to check out the numerous website links!

Crime & Punishment

Information, links and news on law, crime and punishment in Japan.

The Military in Japan

News and information on the US Forces Japan (USFJ) and the Japan Self Defense Forces (JSDF) Be sure to check out the Military in Japan and Japan Research links!

LEARNING & STUDY

News, information, discussion and Japanese language learning resources! Be sure to check out the Japan Blogs, Learn Japanese and Japan Research links!

Government, Politics & Security

Japan-US and Pacific Region news, information and discussion on government, politics and security. Be sure to check out the Japan Blogs and Japan Research links!

Home » Culture & Society, Shopping, Technology

Resident Evil 5: Still a Travesty on All Counts

Submitted by on March 6, 2009 – 2:46 pm10 Comments

314_st_resident_evil_5_up

 

I previously blogged about Resident Evil 5 (When is it not racism and just plain ol’ ignorance). Today I received an email from BlackCommentator.com Columnist, Tolu Olorunda, an activist/writer and a Nigerian immigrant. Olorunda wants to explain where he stands, currently, especially with the barrage of insults he received in response to hiscomments, and with the official release of the game this week. His article follows below. I recommend that you read my article first to familiarize yourself with both Olorunda and my views on Resident Evil 5. Be sure to visit Black Commentator to view additional links to the story and to contact the Olorunda in you have comments.

June 19, 2008, an article is published, with the title “Resident Evil 5: A Travesty on All Counts.” June 20, 2008, an international online community is rallied to war against a writer, for suggestions that a video game trailer “wasted no time in capitalizing upon the long history of blatant depictions of Africans as savages and helpless imbeciles.” He grounded this theory by arguing against the trailer, which, in his words, “featured a Caucasian male mutilating African villages, along with Africans.”Using the “not-so ancient history of colonialism and neo-colonialism in Africa,” he declared that, “the issue of racial insensitivity and indifference must be brought to the centerfold. This patent-reality must be interrogated excruciatingly to expose the silliness of those who claim the 21st century marked the dawn of a post-racial world.” To predict that my sincere analysis of an unequivocally racist depiction of Africans as savages – meant to be shot and extinguished – would result in death-threats, is akin to foreseeing Obama’s presidency, a decade earlier. The gaming community, inflamed by my assertion that the portrayal of Africans, in the Resident Evil 5 series, was inherent racist, launched a grenade of assaults, meant to “teach me a lesson,” about speaking blasphemously against the Almighty Resident Evil (RE) series. This would serve as a model for anyone who dared question the images game-developers concoct for gamers (their specimen) – whether containing of racist elements or not. In the interest of clarity, I stand, unashamedly, by every single word contained in the former article.

One of the major concerns expressed, by the respondents (more like assassins), was my sudden interest in the gaming series, follow the decision to utilize Africa, as the location for the upcoming release. Previous versions had been captured in Europe, South America, Antarctica, and Spain. Many RE players questioned this logic. One of them, like several others, put it bluntly: “Where was Tolu Olorunda when Resident Evil 4 came out and Spanish zombies were being blown away? Where was the outrage then? Where was the anger? Oh that’s right, they were SPANISH. I mean hey, it’s only noteworthy when there’s BLACK zombies right?” This silly interpretation shouldn’t even excite any response from me. That many, otherwise thoughtful, gamers felt it justified to delegitimize my concerns, simply because I did not speak out against the comparable depictions of Spaniards as savages, is a shameful and cynical retort. Though, it speaks to a deeper issue. It suggests that simply because other cultures don’t complain, publicly, about the exploitation of their culture, resources, and heritage, Blacks are expected to fall in line, and be mistreated the same way – without any rejection or resistance. This sentiment defends injustice, for reasons unfathomable.

Another major resentment expressed, was the sheer outlining of the racist agendas championed in the RE 5 trailer. Many gamers convinced themselves, through disciplined self-delusion, that my speaking out against racism, is the essence of racism, itself. They ran laps around logic, arguing that, in 2008 (then), anyone still “complaining” about racism was an accomplice to the system which maintains it. Many gamers echoed that sentiment with unbelievable audacity. A few highlights below:

 “Morons like you are why people are racist against blacks in the first place.”- Anonymous

“You are the reason Racism still thrives. You have jumped on the bandwagon of what I like to call Reverse-Racism. This is where an individual of any race claims racism in everything they see regardless if it is or not. It’s a self pity syndrome… You guys want to latch on to whatever you can to make people feel bad for you.” - Anonymous

“Racism exists due to dumbasses like this guy – want some cheese with that wine? If anything perpetuates racism, it’s retards like you who see it.”  - Anonymous

 “This idiot WANTS people to be racist that way he can cry persecution and gets to keep his job.”  - Oz

Though many gamers claimed to be equally outraged at the racism charge lobbed at their precious series, many of the comments put forth validated my assertions with ease. Hundreds of comments, meant to be critical of me, revealed the sadistic intentions of various RE 5 players, and confirmed what was imprinted in the article – that graphic images play a part in molding and shaping the psychology of the mind, and perhaps, RE 5’s decision to insert a White male, as the protagonist, in the mutilation of those Africans, was simply fodder for many-a-gamers’ fantasies. Most of the comments, as explained, were punctuated by unfettered racist convictions. A few highlights below (Language Advisory):

“YOU MEAN I GET TO SHOOT WAVES UPON WAVES OF NEGROS, AS A WHITE POLICEMAN! SWEET! WHEN DOES THIS GAME RELEASE?”  -Anonymous

 “Niggers need to die anyway.” -Anonymous

 “They should kill niggers in every videogame.” -Anonymous

 “I find Negroids to be the most racist people on Earth and this retarded article only serves to strengthen my views. Negros shouldn’t be wiped out, just the retarded, hate filled, racist ones like yourself Mr. Tolu.” -Anonymous

 “I’m sick of blacks acting like they’re the only race that was ever enslaved. As far as slavery goes, they’ve had it the EASIEST of nearly every group.” -Anonymous

“You’re a stupid fucking nigger and you know it. Did you complain when CJ in GTAIV killed white people? No. So shut the fuck up you stupid cotton picking piece shit.”  -Anonymous

“We don’t hate you. Look what we’ve done for you. We abolished slavery, we built your colleges, we gave you your jobs. If it wasn’t for white people’s sympathy, you wouldn’t be able to post your ridiculous thoughts.”  -Anonymous

“Let’s face it people, and let’s all be honest here. The African people are savages! Why will no one admit to this? Just look at the entire continent, savagery reigns supreme.”-Anonymous

“THE ONLY PEOPLE WHO ACTAULLY THINK THIS GAME IS RACIST ARE STUPID BLACK FOLK WITH NOTHING BETTER TO DO… THEY ARE THE RACIST ONES! I MYSELF CAN’T WAIT TO KILL ME SOME AFRICAN ZOMBIES JUST TO PISS OFF ALL YOU RACIST BASTARDS.” -Anonymous

A few other gamers felt it wise to ask why anyone would “go after” a video game. In their imagination, a video game is as harmless as belief in the tooth fairy. “Really going after a game about Racism?” one commenter queried. “IT IS A GAME,” he/she insisted. Once again, those respondents do the international gaming community a great disservice, with such simple-minded, intellectually-paralyzed comments. Studies upon studies, which have documented the effects of laborious game-playing, cannot be rendered insignificant, to quell the hurt feelings of some gamers. Those studies which link spikes in violence and aggression, in teens and adolescents, and excessive video-gaming, have helped put to bed arguments that maintain games ought to be taken with a grain of salt, for they can do no harm. Judging by the comments listed above, it would be criminal to discredit such great research

The most asinine of the defenses presented came, admittedly, from an unexpected angle. Among other contentions articulated, several gamers suggested that the bulk of my criticism is illegitimate, because the producer of the game is Japanese, and thus, renders all racism charges invalid. “The game is made by japanese people who have never had a problem with slavery or colonialism,” one gamer stated. This great student of history should have been openly berated by his fellow gamers, but that theme soon became recurrent, amongst the community. Beyond the blatant escape of Japan’s enslavement of Korean peoples, the gamer also rejected all evidence, documented by numerous historians, of the enslavement of Africans in Asia.

The anonymous gamer also seemed to intimate that because Jun Takeuchi, the Resident Evil 5 producer, is of Japanese origin, he possesses no racist bone in his body. The U.S. ’08 presidential election would certainly not be registered in the pages of history, before Obama was celebrated as a monkey (apparently, not a phenomenon in Japan), by the Japanese Mobile Company, E Mobile. It was also a Japanese game-show which, a couple of weeks back, rendered a tribute to Obama, with a street-magician performing in Blackface (another norm, reportedly, in Japan).

What should be apparent by now, is that video games are not silly exercises, but rather, complex functions that must be understood, and interrogated, if one is to avoid becoming subdued by the tantalizing impulses they provide. As fans go out this week, to pick up their copies of Resident Evil 5, it is my hope that they understand the responsibility that comes with manipulating images, which resemble historical accounts of genocide. They must come to terms with the images being fed into their (sub) consciousness, and wrestle vigorously with the caution of my speech. I depart with the courageous words of a gamer, who, embarrassed by her fellow peers’ unconscionable remarks, felt the need to pen this reply:

 “The degree of hatred found in this comment thread is mind-boggling. I am so utterly disgusted with the behavior of these ignorant, racist commenters, and I am sorry that you, Tolu Olorunda, have had to endure this vicious abuse. These people are sick. All of the people criticizing you for ‘not doing your research’ before writing this post are completely wrong. I’m a gamer, I’ve enjoyed the Resident Evil series from the start and your post was absolutely spot on. Thank you for having the courage to write this.” -Olivia

  • HokageOFmyHood

    there seems to be alot of racist flaming whenever we bring up that re5 is culturally insensitive. i think we should remember that most of these people are 13-17yr old white kids who hide behind their computer or mic…anyone who played halo online know what i’m talking about.all this racial flaming seems to be a way these people can justify playing a game they know is wrong on so many levels.I’m a gamer and i liked the re series but i refuse to support it any longer after this. i mean did anyone at capcom think or bother do any research or even go to Africa before they made this? is this really how capcom thinks Africa is like?. i know racism will never die but we dont need it in a new market.i can just imagine how many racist will be buying an playing this game just to shoot “savage” Africans.hopefully the media will catch this an put capcom under fire but i donno since they got away with the racist stereotypes in street fighter.it’s sad and makes me ashamed to be a gamer.

  • Kuroyama

    Being a Black gamer I’m going to put my comments in the ring.

    Lets start with the CLEARLY racist comments that proceed mine. Regardless of whether or not the game is or is not racist, or the original argument against the game is borne of sensationalism or oversensitivity, the reaction to said argument was obviously, unarguably racist.

    Most of these writers are closet racists who when online and hidden behind the veil of anonymity will spew forth N-bombs as they have here, will wet themselves at the prospect of confronting a Black man face to face with the same language. Most all rationalize their hate. They maintain that the reason for its existence is the hypersensitivity of the people it targets.

    To wit: violence against a people only exists because its victims are hurt by said violence.

    With regard to RE being racist or not, I will admit to being disturbed by the images of the first trailer I saw. Before any public commentary, before any outrage made its way online, I was simply uncomfortable with it. Black people being made up as savages to be culled by white “heroes” was an uncomfortable proposition for me. However, given the “zombie” premise, it does make sense. I have a much better solution than the one I think was used however: In playing the demo, it seems the zombies have been substantially “lightened”. As if I were to fight an army of Thriller/Michael Jackson zombies. I found that to be AS reactionary as the initial outrage. It didnt quite feel right.

    IMO if you want to find natural “heroes” to an “African zombie” problem… just make the heroes Black!!

    Problem solved.

    Though it may not be quite that simple. I admit I am not a fan of the RE series. What I have played has always felt like a stilted shooter on rails. Its never truly appealed to me. Less appealing still were the unfavorable portrayals of Blacks in the series. Blacks are always portrayed as fearful cowards, or otherwise heavily flawed, and certainly never meant to survive to the end of the game. “Red Shirts” if ever there were.

    In any case, Im willing to overlook that if I can simply get a Black hero with a gun that acts like he has some education, doesnt talk like a pimp or hustler, and exhibits more sense than God gave Orange Road Cones. but this depiction of Blacks seems to elude the RE franchise.

    My problem is not the Black zombies, but the depiction of heroes. Mr. Olorunda, I would ask that you consider THAT. As for the racists that opted take the low road of this topic, I can only hope that you will someday change your perspective on race relations.

  • Nelson

    Kuroyama has made one of the most logical and intelligent comments of this topic, but while I agree with your solution, you must realize that such a game would probably be one of the least profitable games in the series. Intelligent black protagonists are not necessarily rampant in the U.S. and Japan does have a renown fascination with all things Western; hence their heroes follow suit. In Hollywood it has long been noted that the lack of international sales is always factored into how much they are willing to budget certain movies that are slanted toward portrayals of people other than white as protagonists. Why would games, primarily games made in Japan be any different? It would be interesting for more people to try it as the times are a changin’ even if at a snails pace.

  • Vap

    Good post, I don’t usually read blogs throughly. When I first heard of RE 5 I was hype! I’ve played every game since the first one on playstation. I spent my whole summer playing RE II on N64 and so on. This one however has broke my love of the series. I won’t even pirate the game, I have absolutely no desire to play this. I hope capcom does get aired out for this.

    Also for those who say camcom isn’t racist, look at the black people in street fighter. The Jamaican dancer who shakes those noisy instruments and dances after each battle, and Balrog the boxer modeled after Tyson. I’m sure there are more examples but capcom has a history of this stuff.

    As a gamer, I’m done with Resident Evil

  • OneBlackGamer

    Wow, racism has very silly ways of popping up here and there, doesn’t it? This should not be overlooked as it often is. Typically, many video games and movies that make it in the big world of Mass Media are targeted to audiences of most (if not all) Backgrounds and ethnicities. I feel I should address a very important factor in why such a seemingly insignificant detail comes to the fore when compared with other such seemingly insignificant details of the same caliber, like with RE-5.

    The respondent who made the comment about shooting waves of Africans as a policeman may only be responding in such a way due to varying circumstances in his area or neighborhood. Perhaps where he works sees gang activity involving mostly Blacks. Perhaps he was just responding this comment out of sheer sarcasm or sincerity. Whether or not its this or that is besides the point.

    Ones background makes up her personality. Though personalities change frequently through experience, it is often childhood experience, and home life experience that engraves within us as humans what we know and understand.

    It is all but impossible to, through an open discussion thread, determine whether or not peoples views are valid or not, since what makes up their viewpoints varies so infinitely.

    If I could offer a bit of criticism:

    Mr. Tolu. You have every right to challenge accounts of racism if you choose to. Such action is the only way that the Human Race will ever be able to conquer such a stumbling block. However, attacking a well known franchise series created by a mega corporation well known to be racially neutral as far as character design, biographies, and stories go, may not have been so wise. Consider the range of people the company in question has reached. Consider also that bringing up such a topic might sometimes be more harmful than helpful (although very informative) to society’s eye.

    To people who still hold on to racist views and ideas so strongly:

    Insulting a person for using their abilities and their brain is not attractive a thing to do. It does not show intelligence, it does not show open mindedness. Granted people have a right to view things the way they do, and feel the way they shall, however there really is no need to try to inflict harm on others through crude comments and name calling. Mr. Tolu is likely to have more credentials then most to talk on this sort of subject.

    Finally, to people who make really ignorant comments, and you know who you are! (rant alert):

    Have you ever really thought about lame it sounds? To attack an entire race with little slurs or sayings of stupidity? Savages? Really? Have you taken a look through out history. Mexicans were ‘savage’. Africans were ‘savage’. Indians were ‘savage’. Vikings and Pirates were mostly likely ‘savage’ as well. All these people carried reputations with them. But reputations are given, not necessarily earned. Don’t give your mind to a way of thinking until you’ve actually thought about the big picture, from more than one angle even. This is how smart people use their brain power. How murder and self-defense are discerned. How scams and great deals are told apart. How good ideas and even better ideas are weeded out from bad ideas.

    Stupid people abound in every race and in every country. Criminals are not based on their skin color. Savages are not based on where they live. Smart people are not based on their ethnicity or background. There simply ARE stupid people, of both men and women. Don’t be one of them and call some possibly brilliant noble mind a slur simply because of something they could not control.

    Our children watch us. Learn from us. Their foundations are build from us. They react to what we do and say. The future is really through them, but they only learn from the present, their role models. Us! I doubt many Resident Evil loyalists who weren’t already exposed to racist viewpoints would have seen much behind the RE-5 depictions as being any different from the other games in the series until someone points it out.

  • Enrique

    Hey man, bout that RE5 game, Its dumb to call it racist. People who do so should chek this out http://kotaku.com/5165545/an-informed-expert-speaks-out-on-re5-racism#c

  • Tenrou

    @zurui:

    “i am not a gamer but i think the problem for some in the US is that this brings up other issues/problems in American society.”

    I think this is where the main problem lies regarding whether RE5 is considered racist or not. I honestly don’t believe that the developers at CAPCOM designed the game with racist intentions in mind (it probably wasn’t even a thought to them). Considering this is the 19th game in the series, and the various protagonists have been recycled from game to game, they were probably just looking for something new.

    I think the views of the various societies in which the game is released shapes whether people believe the game is racist or not. You’re seeing this with RE5, now.

    Japan saw some of this with “Medal of Honor: Rising Sun.” However, it’s interesting to note what one Japanese gamer said concerning Medal of Honor’s release:

    “…this is a game in which you play as a foreign soldier and try to kill troops from your own country. I bet that you couldn’t even sell a game like this overseas. I have a feeling that Japanese are the only people who would brush this off because ‘it’s only a game.’ I don’t know if that’s good or bad…” http://www.gamespot.com/gamecube/action/medalofhonorrisingsun/news_6084198.html

    I think for those outside of Japan, the depictions of RE5 look blatantly racist. For the Japanese, “it’s only a game”…

  • http://www.blacktokyo.com zurui

    What’s your take on this? http://tinyurl.com/ae9eap

  • Dragon Horse

    I personally thought this whole thing silly. The game is not racist. How many of you play resident evil? They have had games focused on Russia, the MidWest, and Spain (resident evil 4 was in “Europe” but it seems everyone spoke Spanish). The Europe was in a rural village full of backward hicks.

    The new RE5, has a black main character who also fights, and a white main character (the lead character I admit). Are you telling me that you can’t have a game based in Africa with zombies that need killing, when the premise of the game is to stop an evil corporations (headed by whites) from spreading this man-made virus in Africa. With a black woman also trying to help stop this from happening in Africa?

    I could care less what some keyboard warrior child says online, I’ve learned to ignore that a long time ago, but to say the game is racist simply because it shows black zombies is stupid.

    Are you guys saying black folks can’t ever be bad guys in a movie or game without it being racist? I was happy with this season of 24, that actually showed a intelligent black African bad guy…seems that when we do not allow things like this we deny black people humanity. Reality is we cover the entire spectrum from poor backward villages, to warlords, to CEOs, to athletes, to just a middle class guy who works everyday and takes care of his family. This is just like every other group of humans on the planet.

  • http://www.blacktokyo.com zurui

    Here is the Wall Street Journal’s take on RE5: Stereotypes do not merely reflect ignorance [...] through stock racial ideas, but through dominant ideas of race. Link: http://twurl.nl/k4z1zr

    Interesting take on the “everyday guy.”

    i often come across the response about the spanish killed in RE4. i wonder if there were issues with RE4 overseas? i am not a gamer but i think the problem for some in the US is that this brings up other issues/problems in American society. i grew up playing flight and military games. my exposure to the hero in these shoot ‘em up games reinforced that none were like me!

    to flip the script, i recently asked a gamer what would be the response if CAPCOM created a game with a japanese or african/african-american/arab/non-white as the hero killing whites. the response was interesting and the guy felt uncomfortable about the thought of blacks destroying a piece of fictional white suburbia. bio-hazard or not!

    Mike Smith rehashes what ex-Newsweek writer, Croal, had this to say: http://videogames.yahoo.com/feature/resident-evil-5-in-race-storm/1295905

UA-4539196-1